BUYING GUIDE · UPDATED NOVEMBER 7, 2026
Best Payroll Services for Small Business
Compare Patriot Software, Gusto, ADP RUN, OnPay, and Paychex for small-business payroll, including tax filing, HR tools, pricing structure, support, and best-fit use cases.
What to focus on: Use your real employee count, contractor count, states, benefits needs, and pay schedule when comparing total cost.
Compensation disclosureBusiness Service Scout may earn compensation from some clearly labeled partner links. Paid relationships do not buy a positive review. Learn how we make money ↗
How to use this guidePeople searching for payroll services for small business often see very different pricing and service models. Compare the same headcount, states, pay schedule, tax-filing scope, and support needs before choosing.
This small-business payroll services comparison is a shortlist of useful options from our current provider library, not a claim that one product is universally best. Compare payroll processing, tax-filing scope, employee and contractor support, integrations, service model, and total cost at your actual headcount. Confirm current pricing, eligibility, terms, and features with the provider.
HOW TO CHOOSE
Use the shortlist as a decision tool, not a ranking
Compare these first
- Count employees, contractors, states, and local tax jurisdictions.
- List required payroll, time tracking, benefits, HR, and employee self-service workflows.
- Calculate the full base-plus-per-worker monthly cost at today’s headcount and a realistic growth case.
- Confirm who handles filings, notices, corrections, year-end forms, and support escalations.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Choosing from the advertised base price without adding per-person charges.
- Assuming every tax filing, state, or HR service is included.
- Ignoring how a provider handles corrections, notices, off-cycle payroll, and employee changes.
FREE PAYROLL PRICING TOOL
Run the pricing math at your actual headcount
Instead of relying on the five-worker example below, use the free payroll software cost calculator to compare current published Patriot, Gusto and OnPay pricing for your worker count and number of states.
HOW WE COMPARED THESE OPTIONS
Pricing and features checked against current provider sources
We reviewed the providers using the same five questions: published monthly cost, per-worker cost, payroll-tax scope, multi-state handling, and the extra HR or time-tracking features a small employer may actually pay for. Where a provider does not publish a standard price, we label it quote-based instead of inventing an estimate.
What we verified
- Patriot: Basic Payroll is $17/month + $4 per worker paid; Full Service is $37/month + $5 per worker paid. One state is included in Full Service and each additional state is currently $12/month.
- Gusto: Simple is $49/month + $6/person; Plus is $80/month + $12/person; Premium is $180/month + $22/person.
- OnPay: Payroll Essentials is $49/month + $6/worker and currently includes unlimited pay runs plus federal, state and local tax filings.
- ADP RUN and Paychex: pricing depends on the business and service package, so request an itemized quote.
Official sources used
Checked November 7, 2026. Standard published pricing is shown before temporary promotions. Provider terms can change.
FIVE-EMPLOYEE EXAMPLE
What would the published starting payroll price be for five workers?
This example uses five paid workers in one state and the provider's published standard pricing checked November 7, 2026. It is a software/service-price comparison only—not an estimate of wages, employer payroll taxes, benefits or insurance.
| Provider / plan | Published formula | 5-worker monthly example | Important context |
| Patriot Full Service | $37 + $5 per worker paid | $62/month | Full-service tax filing; one state included. Additional states currently add $12/month each. |
| Gusto Simple | $49 + $6 per person | $79/month | Designed for basic payroll in one state; higher tiers add broader time, HR and multi-state features. |
| OnPay Payroll Essentials | $49 + $6 per worker | $79/month | Published base plan includes unlimited pay runs and federal, state and local tax filings. |
| RUN Powered by ADP | Custom quote | Request quote | Pricing varies with workforce and selected payroll/HR services. |
| Paychex | Plan / quote dependent | Request quote | Compare implementation, payroll frequency, HR options and support scope in the quote. |
Arithmetic: Patriot $37 + (5 × $5) = $62. Gusto $49 + (5 × $6) = $79. OnPay $49 + (5 × $6) = $79. Temporary discounts are intentionally excluded so the comparison is easier to repeat later.
OPTIONS TO RESEARCH
5 providers worth comparing
GSmall-business payroll with integrated HR and benefits options. Best fit: Small businesses wanting payroll and HR/benefits in one ecosystem.
- Automated payroll taxes
- Unlimited payroll runs on eligible plans
- HR and benefits integrations
Cost structure: Checked Nov. 7, 2026: Simple $49/month + $6/person; Plus $80/month + $12/person; Premium $180/month + $22/person. Optional services can add cost.
PSStraightforward small-business payroll with published base-plus-worker pricing. Best fit: US small businesses wanting a choice between self-managed payroll taxes and full-service tax filing.
- Unlimited payroll runs
- Basic or Full Service payroll tax handling
- Direct deposit and employee/contractor tools
Cost structure: Checked Nov. 6, 2026: Basic $17/month + $4 per worker; Full Service $37/month + $5 per worker. Add-ons and extra-state charges can apply.
RPPayroll backed by a large payroll provider with room to add HR services. Best fit: Businesses that value a large provider and a service-oriented payroll relationship.
- Payroll processing
- Payroll tax services
- Employee self-service
Cost structure: Quote-based and dependent on team size and services selected.
OFull-service payroll with straightforward small-business positioning. Best fit: Small businesses wanting full-service payroll with transparent plan structure.
- Full-service payroll
- Tax filing and payments
- HR and benefits integrations
Cost structure: Checked Nov. 7, 2026: Payroll Essentials $49/month + $6/worker. HR, time tracking and compliance add-ons can increase the monthly total.
PPayroll and HR packages with multiple service levels. Best fit: Small to midsize employers that want payroll plus expandable HR services.
- Payroll and tax administration
- Employee self-service
- HR and workforce options
Cost structure: Plan and quote dependent; total cost changes with service level and workforce needs.
SIDE BY SIDE
Compare the shortlist
| Provider | Best fit | Capabilities highlighted | Cost structure | What to verify |
|---|
| Gusto | Small businesses wanting payroll and HR/benefits in one ecosystem. | Automated payroll taxes · Unlimited payroll runs on eligible plans · HR and benefits integrations | Checked Nov. 7, 2026: Simple $49/month + $6/person; Plus $80/month + $12/person; Premium $180/month + $22/person. Optional services can add cost. | Compare plan tiers, per-person fees, support, time tracking, benefits availability, and multi-state needs. |
|---|
| Patriot Software | US small businesses that want transparent payroll pricing and a choice of tax-service levels. | Unlimited payroll runs · Basic or Full Service payroll tax handling · Direct deposit and worker portals | Checked Nov. 6, 2026: Basic $17/month + $4 per worker; Full Service $37/month + $5 per worker. Add-ons and extra-state charges can apply. | Confirm current pricing, tax-service scope, direct-deposit timing, extra-state fees, add-ons, and US employee coverage. |
|---|
| RUN Powered by ADP | Businesses that value a large provider and a service-oriented payroll relationship. | Payroll processing · Payroll tax services · Employee self-service | Quote-based and dependent on team size and services selected. | Request a detailed quote covering setup, payroll frequency, tax services, HR add-ons, contract terms, and support level. |
|---|
| OnPay | Small businesses wanting full-service payroll with transparent plan structure. | Full-service payroll · Tax filing and payments · HR and benefits integrations | Checked Nov. 7, 2026: Payroll Essentials $49/month + $6/worker. HR, time tracking and compliance add-ons can increase the monthly total. | Check total worker count, HR add-ons, benefits, workers comp, and any special payroll requirements for your industry. |
|---|
| Paychex | Small to midsize employers that want payroll plus expandable HR services. | Payroll and tax administration · Employee self-service · HR and workforce options | Plan and quote dependent; total cost changes with service level and workforce needs. | Compare package scope, support level, implementation, per-payroll charges if any, and add-on pricing. |
|---|
COMMON QUESTIONS
Before comparing providers: see which payroll taxes are withheld versus paid by the employer, and use our employee cost estimator to estimate a fuller labor budget. These explain the inputs you will need to compare actual payroll quotes fairly.
Small-business payroll service questions
What does a small-business payroll service usually do?
Depending on the plan, a payroll service may calculate wages and withholding, process direct deposits, prepare payroll reports, and handle specified payroll tax filings and payments. Confirm the exact filing scope, supported states and localities, correction process, and what remains the employer’s responsibility.
How should I compare payroll service cost?
Calculate the base fee plus per-employee or per-contractor charges, pay-run fees if any, state or local add-ons, year-end forms, time tracking, HR tools, benefits administration, and implementation costs. Compare the total at today’s headcount and a realistic growth case.
Can a small business outsource payroll processing?
Yes. Many providers offer full-service payroll processing, but “full service” does not mean the employer has no responsibilities. The business still needs to provide accurate worker, wage, tax, and banking information and review notices or exceptions.
Does an affiliate relationship decide which provider appears here?
No. Business Service Scout separates editorial provider data from referral URLs and may include providers that do not pay us.
FIRST PAYROLL CHECKLIST
Paying your first employee?
Before choosing software, confirm employer registration, worker classification, pay frequency, state rules, tax deposits, and what the provider actually files for you.
Read the first-payroll setup checklist ↗FREE HIRING BUDGET TOOL
What will another employee cost your business?
Wage rates alone do not cover all employer expenses. Use our editable employee-cost estimator to model hours, employer-paid benefits and other costs. The tool does not calculate payroll taxes or process payroll.
Estimate employee cost ↗COMPARE BEFORE YOU SUBSCRIBE
How to compare payroll quotes for the same business
Suppose a fictional service company has eight employees, runs payroll every other week, and operates in one state. You should request complete quotes for that same situation from each provider. Comparing an advertised base price on one website with a customized quote from another does not tell you which costs less.
Illustrative cost comparison—these are not real provider prices
Imagine fictional Quote A costs $45 a month plus $6 per employee. For eight employees, that's $93 a month before any extras (45 + 8 × 6). Fictional Quote B costs $70 a month plus $3 per employee: $94 a month (70 + 8 × 3). The $1 difference is irrelevant if one quote excludes tax filings or a feature you require.
Use these examples only to understand the math. Request current written quotations directly from Patriot Software, Gusto, RUN Powered by ADP, OnPay, or Paychex, then compare each quote's actual terms. We have not assigned a universal winner, and we do not assume all providers offer identical services.
Which payroll-service approach best matches your situation?
One employee or a very small team
Look for understandable setup, state compliance support, pay-run timing and a clear minimum cost. Check whether the provider can handle the forms you need without expensive add-ons. Start with our first employee checklist.
Hourly employees with variable schedules
Focus on timesheet imports, overtime and paid-time-off workflows, approval before payday, and correction handling. Check your current wage-and-hour rules rather than assuming your payroll provider chooses the right classification.
Employees in multiple states
Ask about state registration assistance, withholding and unemployment coverage, location-specific reporting and whether each state adds charges. Never assume a “multi-state” marketing label includes every applicable local jurisdiction.
Payroll plus benefits or HR
Compare what is actually bundled and what needs another paid subscription. Benefits availability varies by state, provider, and plan. Make a short list of must-have integrations before selecting a tier.
Payroll software is not the same as an employer-cost estimate. Before committing, estimate the overall cost of a position, including wages, benefits and employer-paid expenses, with our
free employee cost estimator. It intentionally does not calculate payroll taxes or process wages.
What matters after you pick a payroll service?
Before the first live payday, verify the employee's details, gross-to-net preview, payment timing, employer tax registrations, deposit responsibilities and correction process. The IRS explains that payroll deposit requirements and payroll reporting are distinct processes. See its employment tax reporting guide, plus our plain-language payroll tax overview.
Which payroll service makes sense for five or fewer employees?
Start with a small example: three hourly employees, one salaried employee and an occasional contractor, all in one state. Before picking a provider, decide whether you need time tracking, full-service tax filing, same-day corrections, benefits and a dedicated support contact. A provider with the lowest advertised fee is not automatically the least expensive after per-person charges and optional services are counted.
How to compare the full payroll bill
Send each vendor the same short requirements sheet. Ask for an itemized 12-month estimate covering (1) monthly base charges, (2) employees and contractors, (3) payroll-run frequency, (4) federal/state/local filings, (5) year-end forms, (6) onboarding, and (7) HR/benefits/time-tracking add-ons. This is a comparison method, not a statement that every provider includes every feature.
What payroll software does not remove from your responsibilities
Even where a payroll company calculates or deposits taxes, the employer still needs accurate worker records, funding, classifications and timely review of tax notices. Confirm which filings the vendor handles and what remains your responsibility. Our payroll tax guide explains withholding versus employer taxes, and the employee cost estimator can help plan costs beyond the wage.
For a direct comparison of two different service models, read Gusto versus ADP RUN. If you are hiring your first worker, start with the first-employee checklist.