b✓business service scoutBuild your shortlist ↗
PAYROLL & HR · PUBLISHED NOVEMBER 7, 2026

How Much Does Payroll Cost for 5 Employees?

A five-person team is small enough that every monthly fee matters, but large enough that doing payroll manually can get old fast. Here’s how to compare the real cost without getting distracted by a cheap-looking base price.

Published November 7, 2026Payroll & HRPractical small-business educationEditorial standards ↗
EDITORIAL NOTE

How to use this guide

This guide is written for small-business owners who want the practical version first. Examples are illustrative, provider terms can change, and financial, tax or legal details should be checked against current official guidance and the exact product terms that apply to you.

Our editorial standards ↗

The short answer

For a business with five employees, the real payroll bill is usually more than the number in the big font on a pricing page. You may have a monthly base fee, a per-person charge, extra-state costs, time-tracking add-ons, benefits administration, year-end forms, or fees for services that one provider includes and another treats as optional.

The useful question is not “Which payroll service has the lowest starting price?” It is: What will this exact setup cost my business each month, and what work will I still have to do myself?

If you are comparing providers now, our small-business payroll services guide gives you a broader shortlist. This article is about the math behind the quote.

Start with a five-employee example

Imagine a small cleaning company with five W-2 employees. Everyone works in the same state, payroll runs every other week, the owner wants direct deposit, and the company wants the payroll service to handle the normal federal and state payroll tax filings included in its plan.

Now imagine Provider A charges a fictional $40 monthly base fee plus $6 per employee. Five employees would make the basic software bill $70 a month. Provider B charges a fictional $65 base fee plus $3 per employee, which comes to $80. At first glance, Provider A wins by $10.

But what if Provider A charges another $15 for time tracking and Provider B includes it? What if one charges for an extra state next year and the other does not? What if the cheaper plan requires the owner to make certain tax deposits personally? That $10 difference can disappear quickly.

SIMPLE COMPARISON

Do the math on the same business

Use the same employee count, pay schedule, states, tax-service level and add-ons for every quote. If the assumptions are different, the prices are not really comparable.

The five numbers I would ask every payroll company for

  1. Monthly base price. Ask whether that price is promotional or the normal ongoing rate.
  2. Per-employee and per-contractor fees. Confirm whether inactive workers, contractors, or seasonal staff are billed differently.
  3. Tax-service cost. Find out exactly which federal, state and local filings and payments are included.
  4. Add-on costs. Time tracking, HR help, benefits, workers' compensation integrations and faster direct deposit can change the total.
  5. One-time or occasional charges. Ask about setup, prior-payroll imports, year-end forms, corrections and additional states.

Put those numbers into one spreadsheet or note. You do not need anything fancy. The goal is to stop comparing a headline price from one provider with a fully loaded quote from another.

Do not forget the cost of your own time

A payroll service can be inexpensive and still be a bad deal if you spend hours fixing imports, chasing support, or manually moving information between systems. The opposite is also true: a more expensive service is not automatically better just because it includes more features.

For a five-person business, I would pay attention to the parts that actually repeat every pay period: entering or importing hours, checking overtime, approving payroll, handling new hires, making corrections, answering employee questions, and dealing with tax notices if one appears.

If a tool saves twenty minutes once a year, that is nice. If it saves forty minutes every two weeks, that is a different kind of value.

What “full service” can change in the price

Payroll companies use labels like “full service,” but the exact scope matters more than the label. One plan may calculate payroll taxes and file specified returns. Another may include more notice support or state coverage. Some tasks can still remain with the employer.

Ask a plain question: “If I have five employees in one state and run biweekly payroll, what exactly do I have to do after I approve the payroll?” Then ask what changes if you add a worker in another state.

Our companion guide, What Does Full-Service Payroll Actually Include?, goes through those responsibilities in more detail.

What if you only have one or two employees?

With one employee, a $40 base fee matters more on a per-person basis than it does with twenty employees. That is why tiny businesses should not assume a provider designed for a larger workforce will be the best value.

On the other hand, doing payroll manually just because the team is small can create its own cost. A late deposit, wrong classification, missed state registration, or bad year-end form can consume more time than several months of software fees.

If your team is especially small, compare our payroll for one employee guide and payroll options for under 10 employees.

A practical monthly budget for payroll software

I would build a payroll budget with three columns: required now, likely within a year, and nice to have. Put direct deposit, required tax filing, and the number of workers in the first column. Put likely growth, another state, or time tracking in the second. Keep optional HR extras in the third.

Then get written pricing for the first two columns. That gives you a more honest picture than choosing a plan that barely works today and becomes expensive the moment the business changes.

You can also use our employee cost estimator to think beyond software fees and model wages plus other employer-paid costs. It does not calculate payroll taxes, but it can help with the wider hiring budget.

Common questions

Is payroll software priced per employee?

Many services use a base fee plus a per-person charge, but pricing structures vary. Some features, states, services or plan levels can add separate costs. Always calculate the total for your actual headcount.

Is five employees too small for payroll software?

No. The decision depends on the complexity of payroll and the value of your time, not just the number of workers. Even a one-employee payroll can involve tax deposits, forms, records and deadlines.

Should I choose the cheapest payroll provider?

Not automatically. Compare what is included, the work left to you, support, correction handling and the total cost at your actual employee count.

RELATED RESOURCES

Keep comparing from here

General educational information. Payroll pricing and tax responsibilities vary by provider, location and business circumstances.

TRY YOUR OWN TEAM SIZE

Change the worker count

The five-person example is only one scenario. Use our free payroll software cost calculator to compare published plan prices for 1, 5, 10, 25, 50 or your own number of workers.