b✓business service scoutCompare payroll services ↗
FREE · NO SIGNUP · STANDARD PRICING CHECKED NOVEMBER 7, 2026

Payroll software cost calculator

Enter your worker count and number of states to compare the published standard monthly subscription price for several small-business payroll plans.

Important: This compares payroll software/service pricing—not employee wages, employer payroll taxes, benefits, workers’ compensation, or insurance. Plans also differ in tax-filing and HR scope.

The calculator uses currently published standard pricing from Patriot Software, Gusto and OnPay. Temporary promotions are excluded so you can repeat the math later. ADP RUN and Paychex are not included because their standard small-business prices are quote-dependent rather than a simple public formula.

Compare published payroll plan costs

Your payroll setup

Count employees and contractors the way each provider bills them. This is a planning comparison; confirm the provider’s current billing rules before subscribing.

Your published-price comparison

Provider / planPublished formulaMonthlyAnnualScope note

Annual figures are monthly subscription price × 12. They do not include setup costs, optional add-ons, benefit premiums, workers’ compensation, wages, payroll taxes owed by the employer, or changing promotions.

WHAT THE MATH MEANS

The lowest subscription price is not automatically the lowest-cost choice

Tax filing changes the scope

Patriot Basic is intentionally cheaper because the business remains responsible for depositing and filing payroll taxes. Patriot Full Service, Gusto and OnPay include more tax-filing work in the plans shown here.

If your goal is hands-off tax filing, compare full-service options against each other instead of treating Basic Payroll as an equivalent service.

Multi-state pricing works differently

Patriot Full Service includes one state and currently adds $12 per month for each additional state. Gusto Simple is positioned for payroll in one state, while Gusto Plus supports multi-state payroll. OnPay currently says multi-state payroll is included without an additional state fee.

Published pricing used in this calculator

PlanStandard price checked Nov. 7, 2026What to verify
Patriot Basic Payroll$17/month + $4 per worker paidYou handle payroll tax deposits and filings.
Patriot Full Service Payroll$37/month + $5 per worker paid + $12 per additional stateOne state is included; confirm extra-state rules.
Gusto Simple$49/month + $6 per personDesigned for basic payroll in one state.
Gusto Plus$80/month + $12 per personIncludes multi-state payroll plus broader time/HR features.
OnPay Payroll Essentials$49/month + $6 per workerMulti-state payroll and federal, state and local tax filings are currently included.

Official sources: Patriot pricing ↗, Gusto pricing ↗, and OnPay pricing ↗.

Examples at common team sizes

For one state and no optional add-ons, the published formulas above produce these repeatable examples:

WorkersPatriot Full ServiceGusto SimpleOnPay Essentials
1$42/month$55/month$55/month
5$62/month$79/month$79/month
10$87/month$109/month$109/month
25$162/month$199/month$199/month
50$287/month$349/month$349/month

These are software/service subscription examples only. Feature scope differs. Temporary promotions are excluded.

Frequently asked questions

Does this calculator include wages and employer payroll taxes?

No. It compares the published software or payroll-service subscription price only. It does not estimate wages, employer payroll taxes, benefits, workers’ compensation, insurance or other employment costs. For broader hiring-budget planning, use the employee cost estimator.

Why is Patriot Basic cheaper than full-service plans?

Patriot Basic calculates payroll and payroll taxes, but the business remains responsible for depositing and filing payroll taxes. Full-service plans include more filing work, so it is not an apples-to-apples service comparison.

Why does Gusto Simple disappear for multiple states?

Gusto currently describes Simple as basic payroll in one state. The calculator therefore marks it as a scope mismatch when you enter more than one state rather than pretending the plan is suitable. Gusto Plus is the published tier in this comparison that includes multi-state payroll.

Are temporary promotions included?

No. We use standard published pricing checked November 7, 2026. Introductory discounts can change quickly and would make the calculator harder to reproduce later.

Which payroll service should I choose?

Price is only one factor. Compare tax-filing scope, states, support, time tracking, HR tools, benefits, integrations and correction handling. See our small-business payroll comparison for the broader decision.

More payroll research

Best payroll services for small business · Payroll cost for five employees · What full-service payroll includes · Payroll & HR department

Browse all free small-business tools ↗