b✓business service scoutBuild your shortlist ↗
SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON

Compare Payroll & HR

Compare payroll providers on tax handling, state coverage, employee and contractor support, benefits integrations, HR depth, service model, and total per-worker cost.

Compensation disclosure

Business Service Scout may earn compensation from some clearly labeled partner links. Paid relationships do not buy a positive review. Learn how we make money ↗

QUICK SCAN

Capabilities highlighted in our current profiles

Highlighted means the capability is explicitly called out in the provider summary. Not highlighted does not mean unavailable.

ProviderPayroll processingTax serviceHR toolsBenefits connectionProfile
Gusto✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ HighlightedProfile
Patriot Software✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted Not highlightedProfile
RUN Powered by ADP✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted Not highlightedProfile
OnPay✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ HighlightedProfile
Paychex✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted✓ Highlighted Not highlightedProfile
EDITORIAL DETAIL

Fit, structure, and what to verify

Use this section for the context that a checkmark cannot capture.

ProviderBest fitPayroll engineTax & pay workflowHR / employee toolsCost structureWatch before choosingFull profile
GustoSmall businesses wanting payroll and HR/benefits in one ecosystem.Automated payroll taxesUnlimited payroll runs on eligible plansHR and benefits integrationsBase subscription plus per-person charges and optional add-ons; confirm current plan pricing.Compare plan tiers, per-person fees, support, time tracking, benefits availability, and multi-state needs.Profile ↗
Patriot SoftwareUS small businesses that want straightforward published payroll pricing and a choice between self-managed and full-service payroll taxes.Unlimited payroll runsBasic self-managed tax workflow or Full Service tax filing and depositsEmployee portal plus optional HR and Time & Attendance add-onsChecked Nov. 6, 2026: Basic $17/month + $4 per worker; Full Service $37/month + $5 per worker. Extra-state and add-on charges can apply.Confirm tax-service scope, direct-deposit timing, extra-state fees, add-ons, current pricing, and US employee coverage.Profile ↗
RUN Powered by ADPBusinesses that value a large provider and a service-oriented payroll relationship.Payroll processingPayroll tax servicesEmployee self-serviceQuote-based and dependent on team size and services selected.Request a detailed quote covering setup, payroll frequency, tax services, HR add-ons, contract terms, and support level.Profile ↗
OnPaySmall businesses wanting full-service payroll with transparent plan structure.Full-service payrollTax filing and paymentsHR and benefits integrationsBase plus per-worker pricing with optional HR and other add-ons; verify current rates.Check total worker count, HR add-ons, benefits, workers comp, and any special payroll requirements for your industry.Profile ↗
PaychexSmall to midsize employers that want payroll plus expandable HR services.Payroll and tax administrationEmployee self-serviceHR and workforce optionsPlan and quote dependent; total cost changes with service level and workforce needs.Compare package scope, support level, implementation, per-payroll charges if any, and add-on pricing.Profile ↗

Checked November 6, 2026. This is general product information, not personalized financial, insurance, legal, or tax advice.

RELATED PAYROLL GUIDE

Looking for a shorter buying guide?

Open our best payroll services for small business shortlist for a provider-by-provider comparison of pricing structure, tax filing, support, and best-fit use cases.

FREE COST COMPARISON

Put your own headcount into the pricing formulas

Use the payroll software cost calculator to compare current published standard subscription prices before you request quotes or choose a plan.